Tuesday, January 31, 2012

He Who Shouts the Loudest...

It is one of the perversely sad truths of society that the voice which shouts the loudest is the most influential in that society. The true story rarely becomes the prevailing narrative, and the most logical argument rarely wins debates. Instead, it is the story that is spread by the most vocal sources, and the argument articulated with the most passion, that wins - the truth notwithstanding.
Quite naturally, men and women expect to be told the truth when spoken to. So people have a natural tendency to believe what they are told. When they are told the same story by a variety of sources, this effect is compounded.
And if a man or woman feels strongly about something, then it would stand to reason that they care more about what they are talking about than a less passionate person - and by that logic, that they have devoted more time to studying the arguments involved. Passionate people seem to be more knowledgable than dispassionate people.
The fact is, however, that the world does not work that way. People often passionately care about things they know very little about, and journalists slavishly repeat “facts” they are too lazy to check. Ideology and emotion blind many people from making accurate analyses and arguments. And unscrupulous people lie and manipulate the truth to suit their own ends.
Lies can easily flourish - if their tellers are more vocal and more passionate than the guardians of the truth.
I wrote in a previous post that the Church was unjustly attacked on many matters, based on lies and misinformation. The comparative silence of the Church’s defenders, contrasted with the vigor of Her opponents, is the reason why the lies against the Church have been so pervasive. The lies about the Church have been spread with such vigor that many well-minded people honestly believe that the Church  is evil, and spread that falsehood to their friends in good faith.
The antidote to misinformation is clear – loud, bold declarations of the truth, lived and proclaimed with joy and vigor. Only by boldness and loving, truthful zeal can we hope to counteract the lies that have been spread long before us.


  1. What about he who keeps saying the same thing until the other party gives up?

  2. Excellent point. They, too, win arguments.

  3. I came across this, quite by accident. And was deeply impressed by the irony and levels of delusion in your argument.

    As I don't have any of the accounts to publish under my own name, I'll give my email address so I'm not accused of publishing anonymously:

    1. First of all, thank you for being the first person who actually read and attempted to follow the comment policy on this blog. It is largely unnecessary - I changed the rules to allow anonymity (should one wish to claim it), but I moved to a new site.
      "Tu quoque" is a response that could be levied at a lot of my writing - if one starts from a different viewpoint. Thus, the atheist would consider himself justified in writing something similar... only instead of complaining about the noise of the Church's critics, he would complain about the misguided zeal of the religious in proclaiming their misbegotten creeds.
      In short, where you start dictates where you finish.
      Thanks for reading!

  4. This sounds like you anticipating out current POTUS. Scream FAKE NEWS loudly enough and often enough, and people will believe it


Rules for Posting Comments:
1)All commentary is to be respectful.
2)Foul language/crude commentary is prohibited.
3)Use proper punctuation and capitalization.
4)Keep all posts in understandable English.
5)Refrain from personal/ad hominem attacks.
6) Sarcasm, humor, and witty commentary are welcomed.
All posts that violate these rules will be removed.
And the most important rule:
7) All posts are to reflect a spirit of Christian charity.